Elsevier

Women's Health Issues

Volume 11, Issue 5, September–October 2001, Pages 436-441
Women's Health Issues

Article
Universal screening for domestic violence in abortion

https://doi.org/10.1016/S1049-3867(01)00074-3Get rights and content

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the policy of universal screening for domestic violence in an abortion clinic. Compliance with the policy was low, because only 254 of 499 women seen were asked the screening questions: 58% of Caucasians, 40% of East Asians, and 37% of South Asians were screened (P = .003). Of the 254 women asked about abuse, 38 said they had been abused in the past 12 months, giving a prevalence rate of domestic violence similar to that of the general population. Screening for domestic violence in women presenting for abortion is challenging, but feasible.

Introduction

Domestic violence is widely recognized as a major public health issue associated with injury, mental health problems, substance abuse, and chronic disability. Attendance at health care facilities such as abortion clinics brings women in contact with professionals who can screen for domestic violence and offer information and referral. The questions themselves are an intervention, because they communicate that domestic abuse is an important social/health issue, and that the clinic can be a place where women can turn to if and when they decide to address the abuse.

Section snippets

Literature review

In addition to physical injury and chronic health problems such as headache,1 irritable bowel syndrome,2 and chronic pelvic pain,3 abused women are at risk for depression, suicidal behavior, and substance abuse.4

Health care providers have an ethical duty to diagnose and treat domestic violence.5 Leadership has been provided by many professional organizations, including the American Nurses Association, the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, and the American Medical Association,

Method

The study took place in an urban free-standing abortion clinic which provides medical abortions induced with methotrexate and misoprostol. The clinic sees about 1,200 abortion patients/year. There are three other abortion clinics in the city which offer surgical abortions. A study compared women presenting for medical abortions with those presenting for surgical abortions at one of the other clinics and found that the medical abortion patients included fewer teenagers but otherwise were similar

Results

There were 499 women seen during the time period of the study. There were only 254 (50.9%) who were asked the screening questions. There was a difference in ethnicity in the women screened compared with the women not screened: 58% of whites, 40% of East Asians, and 37% of South Asians were screened (P = .003) (Table 2). About half of the reasons given for not screening were patient-centered reasons, such as that the woman’s English was inadequate, the partner was in the room, or the woman was

Discussion

This is the first report of universal screening for domestic violence in an abortion clinic. The fact that only half of women were asked the questions shows how difficult it is to implement a policy of universal screening. The counselors were all enthusiastic and very positive about this project and were well trained to handle abuse issues. In a less supportive atmosphere universal screening might result in even a lower percentage of women asked. Because it has not been clinic policy to

Conclusion

Screening for domestic violence in women presenting for abortion is challenging, but feasible. The prevalence rate of domestic violence in this population seeking abortion was similar to that of the general population. Overall, the women were receptive to this screening, and we found that this was a good time to offer them information about resources.

Acknowledgements

The authors acknowledge the enthusiasm and support of counselors Skye Stuart, Siri Heiberg, and Chris MacMillan. They thank Ludek Podhradsky and Sandy Basra, who helped with data entry.

References (20)

There are more references available in the full text version of this article.

Cited by (28)

  • Unfit for purpose: A situational analysis of abortion care and gender-based violence

    2022, Collegian
    Citation Excerpt :

    Many clinicians discussed the disruption that occurred to their work areas because of disclosures. In their study of universal screening at a free-standing abortion clinic in North America, Wiebe and Janssen (2001) identified that while screening was part of organisational policy and screening protocols were in place, approximately half of the women presenting for abortions were not screened. This was due to a perceived lack of time, lack of interpreting services or protocols regarding partner presence in the interview room.

  • Should violence services be integrated within abortion care? A UK situation analysis

    2016, Reproductive Health Matters
    Citation Excerpt :

    There are no published articles on integrated IPV interventions within abortion services. Although context-specific and not generalisable, individual studies about IPV disclosure or intervention in relation to abortion services described in detail in the above mentioned systematic review indicate that: IPV questionnaires may be acceptable in abortion facilities;19 non-responding women may differ from responders in that they have undergone more abortions;20 only half the women during a period of universal screening were asked about IPV;21 some women report IPV-defining events although not identifying themselves as experiencing IPV;22 many women wish to talk about IPV with regard to further management or intervention,23 with some citing their doctor as the main source of information;24 and women in violent relationships appear as likely to attend for follow-up23 and more likely to know about community resources.24 Previous situation analyses of abortion generally relate to the provision of safe abortion and quality of care rather than the intersection with IPV.25,26,27

  • Domestic violence on pregnant women in Turkey

    2009, Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine
    Citation Excerpt :

    The effects of domestic violence represent complications that may place the health of the fetus at risk. It was reported that domestic violence has been associated with risk of miscarriages, premature birth, low birth weight, defect of antenatal care, early separation of placenta, rupture of membranes, fetal injury.15–18 As a signatory of the ‘‘Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW)’’ and ‘‘Convention on the Rights of the Child’’, Turkey has certain commitments regarding domestic violence and child abuse.19,20

View all citing articles on Scopus
View full text