Table 3

Characteristics of included studies

StudyStudy designCountry/
setting
Intervention(s) descriptionInclusion criteriaConfounders (variables, how measured)Analysis methodOutcomes of interestTotal participants (n)
Seeland et al, 202020 Retrospective database cohortDerived from electronic health records of multiple healthcare organisations across 17 countriesHormone use: estradiol and CHC.
Hormone use was identified via RxNorm codes 4083 (estradiol), 4124 (ethinyl estradiol), progestins VA:HS800, and systemic contraceptives VA:HS200
Pre-menopausal women aged 15–49 who were COVID-19-positive in the last 7 monthsTriNetX analytics tools were used to assess baseline characteristics including ‘demographics, diagnoses, procedures, and medication’.
No information on exactly which variables were collected or how they were measured
A logistic regression analysis was performed for the combined outcome variable ‘death’ incorporating the propensity score matchingMortalityn=18 892
Mujumdar et al, 202021 Retrospective database cohortTertiary medical centre in the USAHormonal contraception including levonorgestrel-intrauterine device, progestin-only pills, CHC, and injectable progestin reported in medical chartReproductive age women ages 12–49 who tested COVID-19-positiveUncertainLogistic regressionHospitalisation.
Intubation
n=123 COVID-19-positive patients
Costeira et al, 202122 Prospective cohort studyUsers of the application in
the UK
Combined hormonal oral contraceptive use (self-report)Female app users aged 20–45 with BMI between 18–35 kg/m2 Age, BMI, smoking status (self-reported)Binomial generalised mixed models with a log-odds/logit link function used for association
Age: continuous fixed effect.
BMI: continuous fixed effect.
Smoker: categorical fixed effect – never, former, and current.
Sensitivity analyses performed to match the mean and median age of cases and controls for the exposure variables in subsets of users in 5-year age bins
Hospitalisationn=295 689
Chima et al, 202123 Case series41 healthcare organisations participating in TriNetX - data for 8 patients in the USACHC
Case definition: pulmonary embolism: defined using any ICD-10 root diagnostic code; medications 30 days before and after acute PE diagnosis and COVID-19 diagnosis
Paediatric patients <18 years old with PE and COVID-19-positive. PE diagnosed concurrently or within 30 days of COVID-19 diagnosisAge, BMI, race, ethnicity, lab results, medicationsDescriptivePulmonary embolismn=6 girls
Hameed et al, 202124 Case seriesMulticentre multinational study – 10 tertiary care centres in Pakistan, Egypt, Singapore, and the USA‘Oral contraception’
CVT case definition: ‘Diagnosis of CVT was confirmed by at least one of the following imaging studies according to the established criteria: MR imaging, MR venography, CT, CT venography, or cerebral venography
Patients aged 18 or older with ‘recent COVID-19 infection, confirmed either by reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction assay of a nasopharyngeal swab or serum antibody testing for COVID-19’‘Risk factors, clinical features, laboratory findings, imaging findings, COVID-19-related information’Descriptive: frequencies and correlationsCerebral venous thrombosisn=7 women with CVT
  • BMI, body mass index; CHC, combined hormonal contraception; CVT, cerebral venous thromboembolism; ICD-10, International Classification of Diseases, 10th revision; PE, pulmonary embolism.